Return To Amish Where Are They Now?

Net worth featured image

“Return to Amish” is a reality television series that premiered on TLC in 2014 as a spin-off to “Breaking Amish.” The show follows former Amish and Mennonite individuals as they attempt to acclimate to the outside world or decide to return to their Amish communities. Over the years, viewers have become invested in the personal journeys of the cast members, often wondering where they are now after the cameras stopped rolling. This article delves into the lives of the “Return to Amish” cast members, providing updates on their current whereabouts and activities.

Introduction to “Return to Amish”

“Return to Amish” has captivated audiences with its unique look into the lives of individuals leaving their strict Amish communities to explore the modern world. The show has documented the challenges and triumphs these individuals face, from adapting to new technology and fashion to dealing with family pressures and the pull of their old lives. As the series has progressed, fans have become attached to the cast and their stories, often seeking updates on their lives after the show.

Where Are They Now: Cast Updates

The cast of “Return to Amish” has seen many changes over the years, with some members leaving the spotlight while others continue to share their lives with the public. Here’s a look at where some of the most memorable cast members are today.

Abe and Rebecca Schmucker

Abe and Rebecca were one of the first couples introduced on “Breaking Amish” and continued their journey on “Return to Amish.” They have since stepped back from the public eye, focusing on raising their two daughters, Malika and Kayla. The couple has been relatively private about their current lives, but they appear to be living a quieter life away from television.

Jeremiah Raber

Jeremiah Raber has remained in the public eye, often updating fans on social media about his life. He married Carmela Mendez, and their relationship has had its ups and downs, which have been documented on the show. Jeremiah has also launched a business selling Amish donuts and continues to be involved in various entrepreneurial ventures.

Sabrina Burkholder

Sabrina’s journey has been one of the most tumultuous on the show, with her struggles with addiction and custody battles over her children. However, she has made significant strides in her recovery and is now a mother of two daughters, Oakley and Arianna. Sabrina frequently shares updates on her life and family on social media.

Kate Stoltz

Kate Stoltz moved to New York City to pursue a career in fashion after leaving the Amish community. She has found success as a model and fashion designer, launching her own clothing line. Kate has also been involved in charity work, particularly focusing on education for girls. She continues to share her fashion journey with her followers online.

Andrew Schmucker

Andrew, Abe’s brother, has had a rocky path, including run-ins with the law. However, he has worked to turn his life around and is now married to Chapel Peace Schmucker. The couple has faced health challenges, with Chapel battling cancer, but they have supported each other through these difficulties.

Mary Schmucker

Mary, the mother of Abe and Andrew, was known for her kind-hearted nature and struggles with the Amish church. She has since been shunned by the Amish community but continues to live her life with joy, often spending time with her children and grandchildren. Mary’s updates are less frequent, but she remains a beloved figure among fans of the show.

Life After the Show

The transition from Amish life to the modern world is not an easy one, and the cast members of “Return to Amish” have each handled it in their own way. Some have embraced their newfound freedom, while others have found a balance between their Amish upbringing and the outside world. The show has provided a platform for these individuals to share their stories, but their journeys have continued off-screen.

Challenges Faced by Cast Members

The cast of “Return to Amish” has faced numerous challenges since leaving their communities. Adapting to a new lifestyle, dealing with family estrangement, and navigating personal issues like addiction and legal troubles have all been part of their stories. Despite these obstacles, many have found strength and resilience, building new lives for themselves.

Success Stories

While there have been struggles, there have also been success stories among the “Return to Amish” cast. Kate Stoltz’s fashion career, Jeremiah Raber’s entrepreneurial efforts, and Sabrina Burkholder’s recovery and motherhood are just a few examples of how the cast members have thrived since the show.

Staying Connected with Fans

Social media has played a significant role in allowing fans to stay connected with the “Return to Amish” cast. Many cast members are active on platforms like Instagram and Twitter, where they share updates on their personal lives, interact with fans, and sometimes even address rumors or misconceptions about their lives post-show.

Cast Members’ Social Media Presence

The social media presence of the cast varies, with some being more active than others. Kate Stoltz, for example, regularly posts about her fashion work, while Abe and Rebecca Schmucker prefer to keep a lower profile. Jeremiah Raber is known for his candid posts and engagement with fans.

Impact of “Return to Amish” on Cast Members

Being on “Return to Amish” has had a profound impact on the lives of the cast members. The show has provided opportunities for personal growth, career development, and public support during difficult times. It has also brought challenges, including public scrutiny and the pressure of sharing personal struggles with a wide audience.

Opportunities and Challenges

The opportunities that have come from being on “Return to Amish” include career advancement, public speaking engagements, and the chance to be advocates for those with similar backgrounds. However, the challenges can be significant, with the cast facing judgment from both their Amish communities and the general public.

FAQ Section

  • Is “Return to Amish” still airing new episodes?
    As of my knowledge cutoff in 2023, “Return to Amish” has not been officially canceled or renewed for a new season. Fans should check TLC’s announcements for the latest information.
  • How accurate is “Return to Amish” in depicting Amish life?
    While the show provides insight into the Amish lifestyle, it is important to remember that it is a reality TV show and may not fully represent the complexity of Amish culture.
  • Have any cast members returned to the Amish lifestyle?
    Some cast members have explored the idea of returning to their Amish roots, but most have continued to live outside of the community.
  • Can fans meet the cast of “Return to Amish”?
    Some cast members make public appearances or attend events where fans can meet them. Social media is also a way to interact with them.
  • What is the best way to keep up with the “Return to Amish” cast?
    Following the cast members on social media is the best way to receive updates on their lives and activities.


The cast of “Return to Amish” has taken viewers on a unique journey through their transition from Amish life to the modern world. While the show has ended for some, their stories continue to unfold in real life. From pursuing careers and overcoming personal challenges to starting families and finding new identities, the cast members have shown resilience and determination. Their experiences serve as a reminder of the complexities of cultural integration and the human capacity for change. As they move forward, fans can continue to follow their progress and support them in their endeavors outside of the Amish community.

You May Also Like